Terrence Higgins Trust uses cookies to improve your experience of our websites. For more information or to change the use of cookies, please click here.

Accept and Close

Background to prosecution and the law

background to the law

You may have heard or read about prosecutions for HIV transmission that have happened in England, Scotland and Wales. Some people have been found guilty and sent to prison.

For people with HIV this can raise a number of questions. In this article we will try to explain the law in as straightforward a way as possible. We will answer some of the most common questions and concerns you may have.

This article is not a substitute for expert legal advice. If you are involved in a prosecution, particularly if you are being prosecuted, it’s extremely important to get expert legal advice. Call THT Direct for a referral.


Has anyone been prosecuted for reckless transmission in the UK?

Prosecutions have happened, not just for HIV but also for sexual transmission of other infections - for example hepatitis B and C.

This article focuses on HIV, which is still the subject of nearly all investigations and prosecutions. However, much of the advice applies equally to other sexually transmitted infections (STIs).

Terrence Higgins Trust doesn’t think it’s useful to prosecute people for any transmission that’s not intentional.

However, we aim to provide an objective account of the law and we give advice based on that. We have helped many people on all sides of cases to negotiate their way through complex situations and get emotional support. We’re here for everyone who has HIV or STIs, or who is at risk of getting them.


Is the law different in Scotland?

The law is different in Scotland from that in England and Wales, but prosecutions have happened in all three countries. However, in most cases much of the process is similar. Where things differ we will make that clear.

For example, in England and Wales you can only be prosecuted if you have actually passed on HIV. In Scotland, you can also be prosecuted for putting someone at risk through unprotected sex.

The other key difference is that in England and Wales, there is clear guidance from both the Association of Chief Police Officers (ACPO) and from the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) as to when prosecutions can take place and how they should be managed.

In Scotland, new guidance was released in 2012 by the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) but the local police have not yet released one.

THT is working with others to clarify this and interpret the guidance for the general public.

Please note:

The information in these web pages was correct at the time of writing. The legal situation around transmission of HIV is evolving with each court case, and information should be checked for accuracy in light of most recent developments.


More on prosecutions for HIV transmission:


Next: How the law works ››

 

Rate:

Whole Star Whole Star Whole Star Whole Star Whole Star (1 vote cast) Please log in or register to vote. What's this?

Save:

Please log in or register to add this article to My favourites. What's this? Adding an article to My favourites will allow you to easily come back to it later or print it.


Your comments

You will need to be logged in before you can leave a comment.

Please log in using the form on the top right of the page or register.

The Information Standard: Certified member

This article was last reviewed on 16/9/2015 by Anna Peters

Date due for the next review: 16/9/2018

Content Author: Daisy Ellis

Current Owner: Policy

More information:

Policing Transmission, Terrence Higgins Trust & NAT, 2008.

Prosecutions for HIV transmissions, Terrence Higgins Trust, 2010.

Intentional or Reckless Sexual Transmission of Infection guidelines from The Crown Prosecution Service.

Criminalisation of HIV, NAT resource.

New Prosecution Policy on Intentional or Reckless Transmission of, or Exposure to, Sexually Transmitted Infections from Scotland’s Prosecution Service (COPFS).